Barton Carroll is a rare breed


As time goes by, I find that it becomes harder and harder to find quality storytellers in music. Barton Carroll is one of the few exceptions. After touring and recording with Crooked Fingers, Carroll decided to develop his solo career with his second album, Love & War. With guitar in hand, Carroll delicately crafts engaging stories through a diverse musical array of acoustic and electric guitar styles. From teenage war refugees to mothers in times of financial depression, Carroll often uses characters from the past as a tool for musical creation. With aged vocals that are comparable to Nick Cave, Carroll uses all of his skills to create extremely memorable songs.

‘Cat On A Bench’ is one of Carroll’s more electrical-oriented songs, with a striking electric violin slowly weeping behind a jagged electric guitar. As one of the catchier and more accessible songs on the album, Carroll creates the song as a masterful depiction of isolation and weariness, comparing a lonely cat stranded in the middle of the ocean to human isolation. ‘Scorched Earth’ is touched by a frail piano, being one of the most emotional on the album. Carroll is young, though his vocals and musical intellect sound like a musical legend in his late 60s. “Can I sing you to sleep, can I woo you to bed?” Carroll implores desperately, “would you put your hands on me, out of mercy?” ‘Her Bright Smile Haunts Me Still’ is his most direct and simplistic, though it is also the most vivid out of the three. Telling the tale of a lost love over is something that Carroll does seemingly well. A sole acoustic guitar starts this one off, until some very dramatic Southern strings complement it beautifully. Barton Carroll is one of the most talented folk artists I’ve heard in some time, so I recommend Love & War to the fullest extent.


Barton Carroll – Cat On A Beach



Barton Carroll – Scorched Earth



Barton Carroll – Her Bright Smile Haunts Me Still



Official Web Site


Mike Mineo

I'm the founder/editor of Obscure Sound, which was formed in 2006. Previously, I wrote for PopMatters and Stylus Magazine.

Send your music to [email protected].

1 Comment

  1. It’s BARTON F-ING CARROLL, man… He won the singer-songwriter slam here in Bellingham at the Green Frog Tavern a month or so back… He is genuinely a nice guy (although, bafflingly, he will deny it.) Look…HE FUCKING ROCKS!! This review is right on. My boyfriend thought he sounded like an old man when he first heard him, too; but he’s a young thirty-something musical/songwriting GENIUS who has an old soul & an obsessive interest in all things related to mankind’s heart of darkness, that is our tendency to brutally slay one another in battle. I hope he gets really famous, then I can tell everybody with pride that he borrowed one of my books…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.